When I was thinking about Doctor Who December I knew I wanted to share the following item with you. Originally written for the sleeve of the Series 4 soundtrack album, my interview with Murray Gold and orchestrator/conductor Ben Foster was heavily edited for the final CD release. Silva Screen Records did make the unedited interview available as a downloadable file for those purchasing the album digitally on their website, but other than that the complete piece has never been published before.
The date was sometime in October 2008 and the pair were about to head onto their old recording stage at BBC Cymru Wales to record the score for the Christmas 2008 special, The Next Doctor. I found them in typically jovial mood – as you’ll see – and also a reflective one, as four seasons of
Michael Beek, Editor
The End Of The Beginning…
“Ben, don’t look at Michael’s questions in advance, otherwise you get the heads up on what’s coming and I look stupid, which I can achieve perfectly well on my own…” It’s a typically jovial start to my lunchtime chat with Murray Gold and Ben Foster in the canteen at BBC Cymru Wales. The pair have a busy day ahead of them as an afternoon and evening of recording with the BBC National Orchestra of Wales – for the 2008 Christmas Special – awaits them. They are of course in high spirits as usual, the secret perhaps to an enduring professional relationship that has seen them through four series of Doctor Who. Slightly less for Ben actually as the talented orchestrator and conductor made his entrance during Series Two and has since become an integral part of the show’s musical existence.
When you listen to the music of Series’ Three and Four, and moments of Series Two, it’s easy to forget that the first series sounded very different. Indeed the music that accompanied Rose’s first adventures with the ninth Doctor were cut from an altogether different cloth and while it was still unmistakably Murray Gold, it was Murray Gold on something of a synthetic shoestring. With the popularity and longevity of the new series somewhat secured, the music for the following series’ was given more room to breathe thanks to the addition of one of the UK’s best ensembles, the BBC National Orchestra of Wales. Their part in the make-up of Doctor Who’s music, not to mention the appearance of Ben Foster, added a well conceived dose of the cinematic to the weekly adventures of the Time Lord and his companion and since then those adventures have been a treat not just for the eyes, but for the ears as well.
It’s been a dazzling year for everyone involved in the show, which has remained a ratings winner and kept fans guessing through another engaging, colourful and dramatic thirteen episodes. Away from the screen the impact and presence of it has been felt, not least of all in July when music from the series was performed on stage at
Sitting down and chatting with the men behind the music, it was plain to see that while it is often a tough assignment, the results are prize enough. It appears the task of buoying up The Doctor’s adventures through music, not to mention those of the Torchwood team, continues to surprise, challenge and delight them, even after four years.
So guys, four series’ down and who knows what to go; what has this journey been like?
MG It’s been like a very slow-moving train to nowhere (laughs). No. Life’s circular I mean we’ve got to the end which is the new beginning isn’t it, and it’s circular so that means now I’m back at the beginning, or not (laughs).
BF Hang on, let me just re-cap – is it the beginning or the end of the beginning?
MG No, as T.S. Eliot said in his poem ‘East Coker’ ‘In the beginning is my end…’
BF And somebody else said in another poem something about the beginning being the end… what’s that from?
MG That’s Churchill’s speech – “This is not the end of the beginning, it’s the beginning of the end…”
BF Well this is the end of the beginning. Print that, but pretend that I knew it was Churchill though yeah? Not that I had to ask
Did you ever conceive how big this show was going to be when you each started on it?
MG Ben I’ll let you answer that.
BF It was already quite big when I joined it at the beginning of the second series. It was not only a fantastic and exciting thing to do musically, but also in terms of the heritage it was pretty exciting. Also it was already so successful after only six months of being on the telly when I started working on it. Did you know
MG I moved to
BF That’s why you moved to
This is of course no ordinary show; the challenges must be endless.
MG They are. You know one thing I said recently to somebody was that what we’re doing is actually a symphonic score for telly; and it’s really different to a symphonic score for film because people always assume that means you’ve got less space to work in, because film’s more expansive. But actually the opposite is true because you have to compress incident and attention-grabbing kind of episodes into the music, because of the laws of contemporary television. I have to re-set when I actually do a film because I have to remind myself that it’s unlikely the audience are going to walk out and if they do it’s a very low percentage. You’re pretty much guaranteed that ninety-five percent of the people that came in to a movie are gonna be there at the end. With television you can’t think that at all; you have to be just so involved with everything and I think that’s the most challenging thing. Some people say it’s filmic, which it is to some extent, but I think that kind of misses the point that it’s also designed for television; it has the depth of a film score, but it has to be much more dense than a film score. In fact if anything it’s more like early film, you know, back in the old days and silent film – sometimes.
BF There’s an awful lot of spots in this new one that we’re doing today. Every three or four seconds there’s a reason for music to be at that certain point.
MG There is an enormous number of cue hits in an hour-long episode like this one; there’s forty minutes of action music, which is scored through and then twenty minutes of serious melodrama. Also the old idea of turning on a sixpence, that quality that early film composers had where they would very quickly shift in mood, and quite unsubtly. I think we try and give it more subtlety, but we’re still screeching to a halt and turning round and running in the opposite direction really quickly and then going from laughter to tears. The actual range, the emotional range, is so fast because you’re also talking about a childlike perspective.
You can have a film like Titanic which is looking at events from an adult point of view and you’re still missing notes in the range that you get when you add ‘we’re doing it for the children’ because they really want to feel the baddie, they really want to feel the despair, they really want to feel the exuberance. We can out-exuberance anybody and we can out-melancholy and we can out-sorrow, but we have to make it so vivid and primary that it means the moments of ambiguity just sometimes have to compete for room. These things make it very energetic and energy-consuming, just writing them, and anybody who listens to any of the music – even if they don’t know anything about the show – they always say it’s so emotional. It does have an absolute counterpart in the amount of energy that that takes, the more heightened the energy you put in, the more difficult it is to do and the more draining physically it is; it’s more of a marathon. I don’t think I’m exaggerating when I say I really think it’s the most energetic music that any show has ever seen, and it’s barmy in the way that it’s like that… Good barmy hopefully.
Despite the obvious instrumental shift between Series’ One and Three, it strikes me that the music has gotten bigger over the years. Are you getting braver as you go along?
MG Well Ben was much more integral from episodes in Series Three; I mean I was watching an episode from Series Two, the other day – I actually paid ‘cause somebody came round to my flat and said ‘what is all this Doctor Who stuff anyway?’ and I wanted to play them an episode, but I have an American DVD player so it wouldn’t work. So I bought an episode to play them and I thought that Series Two was gonna be all orchestral and I suddenly realised that it wasn’t. What did we have on Series Two?
BF Three sessions on series two; three big sessions. I mean there were lots of big themes that we recorded…
MG None of the orchestral music in that series really started coming in until the space one, the one with the devil?
BF There was some in episode one…
MG Not much, just a few. It disappeared though; there were bits of it but there wasn’t a library of stuff. Anyway I won’t say what episode I downloaded; I can’t believe I ended up paying iTunes to download an episode!
BF But Series Three onwards is when we started doing our kind of regular sessions in
MG There was more of a modus operandi yeah. It was like there was more than just the two orchestral sessions and the session for Christmas; on series three there were sessions for twelve people every couple of episodes, or at least most episodes until the last four.
BF I think the important thing to say about this, the orchestral stuff, is that at the moment while we do come to
MG You have to make sacrifices, like Ben would say “well how much running around music is there? Do we need three trombones, or can we get away with two?” Sometimes when we have just the twelve musicians we have to, like for the Sontarans episodes in Series Four - which were great big invasion of the earth episodes - they were placed within the series at a point where the orchestra weren’t available. We had a bit of an extended section with that though didn’t we…
BF Yeah we had trombones, we had twenty odd players. You know you can do a lot with twenty and I think the thing to remember is that when the music is mixed in with all the sound effects and dialogue, at times there’s only a certain level of it that you hear. So it’s kind of an economic choice – we’ll have three horns, we’ll have a few violins, we’ll not have a cello ‘cause you can’t hear the cello anyway – we can do that with the synths. The mixing of that specific instrumentation for the Sontarans with a lot of electronic noises and stuff gives us a slightly new direction in terms of how we can use instrumentation. So we don’t always have this huge orchestral sound, but we have a sound that is well chosen to fit.
MG We get two orchestra sessions a season; one has to cover the first episode or two and then the other has to cover the finale, but there’s always some great big monster in the middle of it. Sometimes it works brilliantly, like on something like ‘Human Nature’ – which is probably the best small-scored episode that there’s been…
BF That was a really nice starter one…
MG And on ‘’ which was the best small-scale episode this season…
BF That’s a good example because on that one
MG That was ‘Human Nature’…
BF Oh yeah…. So anyway we tried that with the harp and strings and there was this very intimate thing going on with Smith and the Teacher; and that was lovely, we recorded twenty-five minutes of new music for the episode with a small combo…
MG Yeah , and like The Ood’s sound had this very particular arrangement. I mean people remember the song, but the actual cues had a specific sound. ‘Midnight’ had the most particular sound because we just wanted it to be like carnivorous sounding, like a feeding frenzy, and the cues were called ‘Feeding Frenzy’ and ‘The Feed’, and ‘Cars and Trombones’…
BF That was great, for some reason we had a few weeks of not doing anything and he had this great idea for this episode and said ‘I wanna try it with three trombones’ and all this stuff and I was like ‘Okay, great!’. Then I thought well hang on, there’s a lot there in terms of the spectrum of music, we’re not gonna be able to do that type of music – but then I saw the episode and I realised that’s brilliant ‘cause there’s all that dark, cannibal, almost Planet of the Apes Jerry Goldsmith style percussion, with low piano and marimba…
MG It was tribal and slightly savage.
BF Lots of weird sounds; it was such fun and a massive, well not risk, but it was a massive experiment certainly.
MG Yeah definitely… Every episode poses a different kind of problem of ‘How do we do it now?’ It’s like street fighting; in a very cultivated way, you are street fighting on this show because you just don’t know what’s coming up. This year we got the orchestra just at the point when we were gonna do the library episode and I’d already decided we’d had enough War stuff and everything should settle down for the library episode ‘cause that’s the way Steven [Moffat] writes.
|That was one of the only episodes they had to be used for, so those two episodes ended up being very big and I’d always thought of them as being a kind of chamber piece. I suppose all these episodes have the scope to have a large scale somewhere, even ‘Human Nature’ ended with the great big rousing chorus of ‘The Doctor Forever’ so it didn’t stay within its chamber confines. I like them when they do though, it’s really good music.
Were there any specific surprises or challenges in Series Four?BF Well it started with ‘Voyage of the Damned’ which for me is probably one of the best scores so far. It’s so nice to have such a strong theme – ‘Stowaway’ – and have that all the way through the score. It felt like a complete film score, so that was a great kick off.
MG We were worried about
BF It struck me that it was kind of like this Agatha Christie thing and I kind of slightly thought of what I knew from my old days of watching Poirot and that kind of thing, so I thought that chamber sound would work really well.
MG We also slightly nodded to Miss Marple
BF It was brilliant. But that chamber sound was ideal for it…
MG Even on that I wondered “how do we do the Wasp?”, I mean yes it’s all set in a domestic setting, but at some point you still feel you need scale because you’ve got this Wasp monster from space (laughs).
BF But that’s an example of where we did big stuff but with a small ensemble, so at the end of the day if it’s not big enough we just turn it up a bit. There’s enough information there…
MG It’s an interesting thing this, about TV, whether we actually do need the scale or not. I mean you are only subliminally aware of it sometimes. Compared to the attention to detail that we give it, you don’t hear much of it. When we went to watch ‘Voyage of the Damned’ at the press screening, David Arnold said “geez that must have been a lot of work, and you only really only get the ins and the outs”. All you really hear is the big theme climaxes and the big opening scene settings, and everything that’s underneath it you’re just sort of aware of in the way that you’re aware of sound in another room. Even if it is in another room, you’re still aware that there’s something gigantic in that next room, there’s something big going on there.
BF You can’t not do it though, that attention to detail like you say is crucial – there’s no shortcuts to it, you either do it or you don’t.
If it wasn’t there then there would be a hole and if it wasn’t the right thing there it would be wrong, you’d notice. People are very used to hearing huge symphonic music in films that they can barely hear, but again the information that they know that it’s there and also that they’ve heard that type of thing before – you need to give it that otherwise it’s not there.
That’s the beauty of an album of course; you can show off the middle bits…
BF Yeah I mean that’s the nice thing about having the records…
MG Except we don’t necessarily put what’s been in the show on the album; you tend to have a look at it and you can’t help giving it a little gloss sometimes.
Is there a defining moment of Series Four for you?
BF ‘Dalek Planet’ which we recorded here - you were here. For me that was great, so musically that’s my defining moment, the return of the Daleks.
MG The moment that I say “hooray I’ve finished” gets closer and closer to the point where I say “oh my god I’ve started”. I think this summer it was about a week and a half! I actually sent a message to friends of mine - I was sitting in a champagne bar on my own when I did the last tinker on episode thirteen of Series Four - so I sent this message saying “Join me, I’ve finished my work for the year” and they came and joined me, but within a week I couldn’t come out ‘cause I was too weighed down with stuff again. It does get hard, but I don’t wanna talk about it all in terms of it being a chore or of how much you start to long for it to be over (laughs)… We scored big time though; it’s a good series.
So has this album been particularly tough to get right?
MG Jake Jackson should get a co-producer credit for this one ‘cause essentially he’s assembled the album. He’s the poor wretch who had to trawl through every episode of music, trying to flag up the things he thought should go onto an album. I think he ended up with about two-hundred minutes…
BF We’d have ended up with three-hundred minutes though. I think it’s good that it’s somebody who, although Jake was very involved in the process, isn’t too involved. I think it’s good that it’s not you and it’s not me…
MG The funny thing is, the album he came up with first was not a Doctor Who album in the style of the two that came previously. It was very esoteric, very adult sounding and full of cues that were interesting, but not ones that I would want to put on, and not ones I would imagine the kids who buy the album would go to first. So I said “what are you doing?” and he was like “well this is all great music” – these were meandering kind of journeys, kind of abstract, and you forget that that’s in there actually and he managed to get about ninety-minutes of music which was kind of almost Radiophonic sounding, I mean plus acoustics. Away from the episodes the synthesizers sounded interesting, not for a Doctor Who album though; so I kicked his ass (laughs) and told him to go and find some tunes.
And did he?
MG Yeah, and he has edited together more suites this time, so I think the tracks are longer.
I did occasionally say to him “no you can’t throw ‘Song for Freedom’ three and a half minutes into the track” because, again, the kids are gonna want to put on track eleven or whatever it is and have it come straight in. So he said “oh don’t worry, we’ll just put an index in…”, so I hope people don’t complain about it too much. Also there are some points where we might get to a real highlight and I might have kept it going a bit longer than Jake has; but we’re really short of time. I actually thought rather than put two lots of thirty-two bars and make it go round again, the kids can do that themselves and meanwhile we’ll put more new stuff on the album. If they want it to repeat they can make it repeat on their computers; kids, honestly they’re so smart! Ordinary adults will just have to press play again…
BF Build your own Doctor Who album…
MG They do anyway!
You’ve been working together now for a few years; what’s your process..?
MG Well I yawn and go out whoring in
BF It is killing me…
MG No it is killing him.
BF It is hard work.
MG It’s nothing to do with how little I know about orchestration, it’s just speed; Ben orchestrates about twenty times faster. Obviously I know just as much about it all as him and if I was better at computer programming then I could do it.
BF I’m just a whiz.
MG It does vary from project to project, I would say on this Christmas special I probably leant on Ben more than anything before. There’s a certain amount where I can be helpful in terms of suggestions – sometimes there’s already a very clear picture of what sounds I want, then there’s the kind of thing where I just give like all of the notes on piano – so you get all the tune and the harmony, all the notes are there, but there’s really no indication other than that. Then, like for this one, Ben asks for a very general thing… on ‘Runaway Bride’ I said make it Leonard Bernstein-ish and ‘Voyage of the Damned’ was very 1940s. So Ben often orchestrates the whole thing from piano; it’s partly a time thing. There’s no point me just putting everything on electronic instruments; they sound crap and in some ways they’re not even as clear as just having a piano track.
He does stop me taking too many liberties, or sometimes I just refuse to do things and Ben steps in to keep the peace.
What has been the highpoint for you so far after four years?
MG It’s gotta be the Prom.
BF That was crazy… but the concert we did in
MG For me personally, taking to the stage at the Albert Hall and just sneaking down the left aisle, hearing this volume of applause come up and I wasn’t realising it was for me, and then Ben giving me this special count in for ‘Doomsday’ because I can’t follow the conductor (laughs).
BF It was great having
MG I pretty much forgot that we were going out live on [BBC] Radio 3 and that we had an orchestra and two-hundred people on stage and I just said to Ben “come on then, we’re doing an encore, let’s go from section F!”
BF So I had a look at the score and was like okay… “Section K, everyone, K” and they all started joining in and I turned round to the audience like this [starts clapping]. It was brilliant though, definitely a highlight. But walking out on stage at the beginning of it, hearing the audience clap… that was brilliant and absurd. It was a wonderful day…
Where’s all this going then… where are you headed?
MG I don’t think we can answer that… it’s a combination of voices. Ben’s involved in the two movies that I’m doing, so who knows. I’ll tell you one thing though, in the last four years we’ve made some really good music, I mean for both shows, really really good music. It’s got balls, and a lot of love, and that ultimately is worth being happy about.
BF It’s worth the hard work. I listened to that ‘Voyage of the Damned’ score last week and I hadn’t listened to it for maybe eight months; I was proud of everything and was actually surprised at how good it was. I heard stuff I’d forgotten that we’d done; everything is done so quickly, so swiftly, you have to fly by the seat of your pants and rely on each other I guess, in this relationship.
Our Doctor Who December continues later this month with a brand new interview with composer Murray Gold, who discusses his final year with The Tenth Doctor and his outstanding work on the forthcoming Christmas specials 'The End Of Time - Parts I and II' Don't miss it!